Periodical/Journal Chart
Descriptions of various types of periodicals/journals
Scholarly/ Peer Reviewed Journals | Professional/ Trade Journals | Commentary/ Opinion Journals | Popular Magazines | Newspapers |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Examples | American Journal of Sociology Journal of Experimental Psychology |
American Teacher Science News |
Mother Jones National Review New Republic |
Time Newsweek People |
StarTribune New York Times |
Primary Use or Value | Original research | Current trends, professional news, company information | Social & political commentary & analysis, political viewpoints | Entertainment, current events, hot topics, popular culture | Current news, local & regional information, classified ads |
Language/ |
Academic, technical. Written for experts in the field | Written for practitioners. Can use jargon extensively | Most written for a generally educated audience | Non-technical language | Non-technical, written for a general audience |
Authors | Researchers, academics, professors, scholars | Professionals in the field or journalists with subject expertise | Variable: academics, journalists, spokespersons for "groups" | Mainly journalists, occasionally freelance journalists | Journalists |
Source Citations | Footnotes, bibliographies. Often extensive documentation | Occasional brief bibliographies. Some sources cited in text | Occasionally cite sources in text or bibliographies | Rarely cite any sources | Rarely cite sources in full |
Publisher | Universities, scholarly presses, or academic/ research organizations | Commercial publishers or professional/ trade associations | Commercial publishers or non-profit organizations | Commercial publishers | Commercial publishers |
Graphics and Advertising | Graphs, charts, formulas, depending on discipline. No glossy ads | Photographs, charts, tables, illustrations. Some ads for products related to the field | Wide variety of graphics, from plain to glossy ads | Very glossy. Full of color ads | Pictures, charts, ads of all sorts |
Finding Aids/ Access Tools | Some from general indexes like MegaFile, some in specialized indexes like PsychInfo | Indexes like Business Source Premier. sometimes also in general scholarly indexes like Academic Search Premier | General indexes like MegaFile, Academic Search Premier | General indexes like MegaFile, Academic Search Premier | In indexes like Newspapers. Some major papers in general indexes |
Adapted with permission from G. Gradowski, who kindly provided an update of the chart from Gradowski, G., Snavely, L., & Dempsey, P. (1998) Designs for active learning: A sourcebook of classroom strategies for information education. Chicago: ACRL.
Last Modified: 8/15/22 3:44 PM | Website Feedback